end of year

PhiMu, you are NOT #1.

I'm sorry but you cannot actually believe that more people want DZ over Tri Delt, KD, or even XO or ADPi for that matter. Also AXO needs to be way down like below adpi and xo

When did you go to UT? 2005? DZ and AXO are much more popular than ADPI and XO, and in my (and many other's) opinion, KD as well. DZ is definitely better than TriDelt too.

In my group a LOT of girls wanted DZ over CHIO and ADPI. TriDelt was VERY popular as was PhiMu.

I'm going to answer this with my own ranks, each in 5 rows: top, lower top/upper middle, middle, lower middle/upper bottom, and bottom, for each category you stated above. Then I'll post the average. Because yours has nothing to do with the things you said you based it off of.
EVERYTHING IS IN ALPHABETICAL ORDER

Fall Recruitment '15:
DZ/Phi Mu
AXO/ADPI
AOPI/DDD/KD
XO/KKG/ZTA
DG/SK/Pi Phi

Grades ranks from the Pan website:
ADPI/XO (3.4-3.5)
AOPI/KD/PHIMU (3.3-3.39)
AXO/DDD/DZ (3.2-3.29)
DG/KKG/PIPHI (3.1-3.19)
SK/ZTA (3.0-3.09)

And based on involvement:
AXO/AOPI (homecoming/lipsync winners)
DG/DZ/PHIMU
ADPI/PIPHI/ZTA
XO/KKG/KD/SK
DDD (probation)

So without looks involved (because they DONT MATTER) this is the OVERALL AVERAGE:
PHI MU (average row: 1.67)
AXO/ADPI/AOPI/DZ (AR: 2)
XO/KD (AR: 3)
DDD/DG (AR: 3.67)
KKG/PIPHI/ZTA (AR: 4)
SK (AR: 4.67)

If you rank looks (this is my opinion, and everyone's is different because every house has pretty girls and not so pretty girls, it just depends on who you know):
DZ/KD/PHIMU
AXO/DDD/ZTA
ADPI/AOPI/SK
XO/KKG
DG/PIPHI

Overall with looks included:
PHI MU (AR: 1.5)
DZ (AR: 1.75)
AXO (AR: 2)
ADPI/AOPI (AR: 2.25)
KD (AR: 2.5)
XO/DDD (AR: 3.25)
ZTA (AR: 3.5)
DG/KKG (AR: 4)
PIPHI/SK (AR: 4.25)

So your rank should be
PHIMU/DZ (1-1.99)
AXO/ADPI/AOPI/KD (2-2.99)
XO/DDD/ZTA (3-3.99)
DG/KKG/PIPHI/SK (4-4.99)