facebook

sga candidate disqualification

by:    

So as many of you guys know, a candidate for the executive SGA election was disqualified after it was found that she asked her sorority sisters to vote for her, causing her to get about 200 more votes than her rival candidate.

This post is not meant to target the girl or attack her - I have nothing against her and believe she just made an honest mistake. However, I disagree with the whole "petition" to bring her back - rules are rules and she broke them. Had she not posted in the private group, she most likely would not have won. Sure, her sisters will say that they would have voted for her even if she wasn't in their sorority but I'm a little skeptical about that.

Thoughts? Once again, this is not meant to target the individual or her sorority, so please try to be civil and considerate.

Posted By: sorority
Page 1 of 1
#1by:    
#1    

The vote total was 340-94 or something like that, so even if all those votes were invalid, she would have still won handily-and I'm sure many of them would've voted even if she didn't post in the group. And who cares if they voted for her because she's in their sorority? Why does that invalidate those votes?

By: FratStar
by: math   

You can't actually just say that. If you assume that each of those girls would have voted in the election regardless then you can't give all the votes to one candidate without taking them from the other. You can argue that her posting had a potential 400-vote swing. If those 200 girls aren't influenced (as minor of an influence as it may have been), then you could make the argument that maybe those 200 vote for the other candidate, resulting in a 140-294 vote victory.

Of all the things that have been said this argument has irked me so much because it's just flawed. If you're going to argue in favor of her you can't just say "she would have won anyway".

By: math
Report
by: @math   

If he only got 94 (or something like that )votes from a larger community, the probability that he could have gotten enough votes from phi mu to win fair and squire was next to zero.

By: @math
Report
#2by:    
#2    

It's good that her sisters showed some support. Trust me, it's not always the case with sororities. Especially top ones.
The main idea behind joining sororities or fraternities is to find a support group. It goes without saying for frats but girls are often too competitive to support someone who is trying to stand out. It should have been expected that she gets her sorority support and noone supposed to know about her group messages. It should have been a private affair.

By: topsorority
#3by:    
#3    

Not sure why nobody mentions this, but the idea is to tell a bunch of people, and then they go out and also get a bunch of people to vote for her (or whoever). So I don't the whole subtracting the numbers thing is as solid an argument as people think

By: whocares

Before you type:  Please do not post individual names, defaming content, or spam. Remember, cyber bullying can be considered a crime.

Nickname:
Message:

#4by:    
#4    

so dumb. isn't that what campaigning is?
also big props to the phi mu girl who ratted out her sister so that her bf could win an election he lost by over 200 votes...smh hopkins so petty

By: sodumb
by: Yes   

Yes

By: Yes
Report
by: heard   

heard shes getting kicked out of phi mu?

By: heard
Report
#5by:    
#5    

She broke a rule. Changing the rule after a violation would set a bad precedent and make the SGA look illegitimate. The rule about campaigning in closed groups seems sensible. I think it's fair, all personal things pushed aside.

By: Outsider
#6by:    
#6    

I heard all the Betas voted for Sarah too!

By: lol
#7by:    
#7    

guys isn't beta a sorority too... why didn't jack get all of his sister's votes?

By: Wait...

Post Reply

Before you type:  Please do not post individual names, defaming content, or spam. Remember, cyber bullying can be considered a crime.

Nickname:
Message:

POPULAR ON GREEKRANK

Didn't find your school?Request for your school to be featured on GreekRank.